Smith Allen Insurance

Nick is the worst insurance agent I’ve ever dealt with. I used him for three years, and my rates increased every year. When I tried reaching out last year by phone, text, and email, I never received a response. After finally shopping my policies, I found identical coverage for over $1,500 less per year than what I was quoted at renewal. That alone made the decision to leave easy. I would strongly recommend avoiding him if you value communication and an ongoing relationship, rather than just a transactional experience. After I canceled, his response was: “Hope it’s the same company and coverage. Not all insurance companies are the same.” To be fair, this review is not a reflection of Smith Allen as a whole, since I haven’t worked with any other agents there. I’ve seen many positive reviews mentioning proactive communication—calls, texts, and personal touches—which was not my experience. I did receive a call from the owner after canceling, which suggests the company does care about its reputation. While my experience with Nick was disappointing, it does seem that other agents at the firm prioritize building real client relationships.

Drew Stevens made the insurance process simple and found my clients a great rate. He was easy to work with and very helpful throughout the process. Highly recommend. My clients were very impressed with his work!

I had a great experience working with Nick Glenn for my home and auto insurance. He took the time to walk me through my options and made sure I understood exactly what I was getting, without any pressure. The biggest win was the savings—Nick helped me cut my auto insurance costs by hundreds of dollars while still keeping solid coverage. That kind of result speaks for itself.

I’ve worked with Jack Liscio at Smith Allen Insurance and honestly couldn’t be happier. He keeps my costs low and always makes sure I’m getting the best coverage for my money. I would highly recommend Jack to anyone looking for an insurance agent who truly cares—you’ll be treated like family.

I recently had a wonderful experience working with Kyle Heidelberg while securing new auto insurance. The entire process was seamless and stress-free. Kyle took the time to clearly explain my options, answered all of my questions, and ensured I felt confident in the coverage I selected. At no point did the experience feel rushed or transactional. I truly appreciate the level of care and professionalism provided, and I highly recommend Smith Allen Insurance for the support they offer their clients.