All Star Insurance

All Star Insurance is a local insurance agency at 3419 S Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa, FL 33629. The office is a practical place to start when you are comparing auto insurance or homeowners insurance and want to speak with a local agency. Customers describe working with the team as friendly, respectful, and prompt. One reviewer has kept car insurance with the agency for more than ten years and says the office has continued to help when questions or problems arise. That kind of long-term experience can be useful when you want an agency you can contact again, not just a quote you receive once.

Auto insurance is a frequent reason customers reach out. In one review, Jessica helped a customer compare quotes for several cars while they were shopping for a new vehicle, and provided pricing quickly. Another customer was looking for both auto and homeowners insurance and chose this local South Tampa business after reading reviews. These examples give prospective customers a sense of the conversations the agency may be able to support: comparing options for more than one vehicle, exploring coverage for a home, and asking questions before making a decision. The reviews praise Jessica for being honest, timely, and available, and for answering questions thoroughly. Coverage, pricing, and eligibility depend on individual circumstances, so customers can contact the agency to discuss their own needs.

The customer feedback emphasizes personal service rather than a particular office atmosphere or a list of advertised extras. Reviewers describe the staff as kind and polite, and say the team tries to go above and beyond when help is needed. Several customers mention prompt responses and positive experiences over multiple years. That may make All Star Insurance a good fit for Tampa-area drivers and homeowners who value direct communication, want to compare insurance choices, or prefer to work with a local agency. The business has a 4.9-star rating from 29 reviews, though each customer’s experience and insurance needs will be different.

The office is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. and Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.; it is closed Saturday and Sunday. If you are considering auto or homeowners insurance, you can reach out during business hours to ask questions and discuss available options. Customers have also noted that a request sent over the weekend may be followed up with after the office reopens, rather than receiving an immediate response while it is closed. For local residents comparing agencies in South Tampa, All Star Insurance offers a neighborhood point of contact at 3419 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, Florida.