Tanya & Matt's Ice Creamiest

Tanya & Matt's Ice Creamiest is a neighborhood ice cream shop at 15742 N Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa, FL 33618. It is a spot for a scoop, a generous serving, or a relaxed dessert break, whether you live nearby or are passing through the area. Customer feedback describes a welcoming, familiar feel: one longtime guest has been coming since the 1990s, while others say staff greet newcomers warmly. The shop has a 4.6-star rating from 679 reviews, offering a useful snapshot of many customers’ experiences while recognizing that individual visits and flavor preferences can differ.

Flavor variety is a central part of the appeal. Reviews call out creative options such as Junk in the Trunk, Blueberry Cheesecake, and Cherry Amaretto. One customer describes Junk in the Trunk as a combination of favorite ice cream flavors and praises its large serving; another names Blueberry Cheesecake as a family favorite. Cherry Amaretto is also a familiar choice for at least some returning customers. The selection gives guests different flavors to explore, and reviewers mention that a handful of sugar-free flavors are available as well. Since flavors and availability may change, ask the staff what is being served when you visit.

The atmosphere sounds casual and neighborly rather than formal. Guests describe it as a classic local ice cream stop where regulars return and first-time visitors can feel at ease. Families are one natural fit, with a reviewer sharing that visits bring a smile to their family. It may also suit shoppers looking for a sweet treat during an errand nearby; one reviewer appreciated that the shop is beside TJ Maxx. For a simple pick-me-up after a long day, a scoop here offers an easygoing alternative to planning a full meal or occasion.

Tanya & Matt's Ice Creamiest is open Monday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Sunday from noon to 9 p.m. The later weekend closing time can be handy for an evening dessert, while the weekday schedule works for an afternoon stop. Customers also mention a rewards option: add your phone number at checkout to save for future visits. If you have a favorite flavor in mind, checking with the shop before making a special trip is a practical way to confirm it is available.

Experiences are not identical for every guest. While many reviews praise the ice cream, creative flavors, generous portions, friendly service, and welcoming neighborhood character, one reviewer describes disappointment with a Cherry Amaretto serving that did not match what they expected. That contrast is useful context when deciding what to order: share your flavor preferences with the staff, ask about ingredients or current batches, and choose from what is available that day. For visitors seeking a relaxed dessert stop in Tampa, Tanya & Matt's Ice Creamiest brings together a broad flavor selection, familiar favorites, and a local-shop feel.